PC receivers sensitivity
Added by Martin Bednar over 8 years ago
Hi,
I'm experiencing a consistent difference between PC DVB-[TS] dongles and dedicated receivers (be it integrated in TV sets or a satellite receiver box), with the PC side of the equation faring worse.
Hardware this happens with :- dual AF-9015 (dvb-t)
- DVBSky S950C (dvb-s)
- Some pinnacle dvb-t usb dongle.
This is likely not a tvheadend issue (also tried with Kaffeine).
What this basically means is that on my HTPC I consistently get less channels than with the dedicated receivers.
Anyone experiencing this too? Any ideas if it is fixable?
Thanks.
Replies (4)
RE: PC receivers sensitivity - Added by Jonathan Thomson over 8 years ago
Unfortunately the inside of a PC case is very noisy from an electrical perspective, there's a lot of components that can (and do) cause interference so if your signal is less than perfect you will notice issues.
Anecdotally I've noticed the opposite, our DVB-T feed to the house is patch, we have a TV in the kitchen that on some days struggles to keep a stable picture whilst my TVHeadend/Kodi setup works almost perfectly from the same feed.
Further anecdotally I've just switched from the closed source to open source TBS DVB drivers and noticed the signal strength/quality has improved by about 20% over the closed source variants so drivers do impact the equation too.
In short, it's not an exact science unfortunately.
RE: PC receivers sensitivity - Added by Martin Bednar over 8 years ago
I tried a different DVB-S receiver (TBS 6981) and it seems the S950C just has shitty sensitivity (under linux?); Now I get all channels I expect, based on kingofsat.net.
I'll try whether this is linux specific (will finally try the pci passthrough feature of qemu)
Thanks.
RE: PC receivers sensitivity - Added by Jonathan Thomson over 8 years ago
I found exactly the same - I "replaced" my TBS cards with DVBSky ones after getting a new motherboard and finding it wasn't backwards compatible with PCI-E v1.0 (WTF?!) but found the DVBSky cards to be very flaky in terms of signal quality/strength from the same feed. Thankfully I've switched back to the TBS cards which are rock solid.
I've been running the open source TBS drivers (from https://github.com/ljalves/linux_media/wiki) and have to say they are far more reliable/stable than the TBS ones (which to be fair were pretty good). Worth giving them a bash to see if it improves things.
RE: PC receivers sensitivity - Added by Martin Bednar over 8 years ago
Running the TBS 6981 with OSS drivers now, works great. The S950C simply sees only half the channels. Some day I'll try the windows drivers, just to know.